Radio News Network Radio News Network
ISLAMABAD – As Pakistan gears up for its pivotal 5G spectrum auction, the country’s major telecom operators have laid bare a litany of governance shortcomings plaguing the sector, issuing a stark ultimatum: without urgent structural reforms, the dream of nationwide 5G deployment could crumble under the weight of outdated policies, punitive taxes, and bureaucratic inertia.
In a unified set of proposals submitted to the government, industry heavyweights like Jazz, Telenor, and Ufone have not only outlined survival strategies for the high-stakes auction but also spotlighted systemic failures that they argue are throttling investment and innovation. At the heart of their critique is a regulatory framework that exposes operators to volatile economic risks while saddling them with fiscal burdens ill-suited for a capital-intensive transition to next-generation networks.
Foremost among the governance gaps highlighted is the archaic practice of pricing spectrum in U.S. dollars—a relic of past auctions that leaves telecom firms vulnerable to Pakistan’s notorious currency fluctuations. “This isn’t just inefficiency; it’s a policy blind spot that turns global market forces into domestic disasters,” the operators’ joint statement implies, as they demand a shift to Pakistani rupees with payments pegged to a stable exchange rate mechanism. To compound the issue, they’ve called for a 10-year, interest-free instalment plan, underscoring how short-sighted financing terms exacerbate cash flow crises in an industry already reeling from underinvestment.
The proposals peel back layers of deeper regulatory dysfunction, painting a picture of a government apparatus that has failed to evolve alongside technological imperatives. Operators have proposed a minimum price threshold to safeguard market sustainability, warning that unchecked erosion of tariffs could doom 5G viability. They’ve set an ambitious yet pragmatic target: boosting Average Revenue Per User (ARPU) to USD 2 within three years. Yet, this goal hinges on addressing what they describe as “unrealistic pricing benchmarks” enforced by fragmented oversight, which stifle operators’ ability to balance affordability with the massive outlays needed for infrastructure.
Taxation emerges as another glaring governance chasm, with the industry decrying a patchwork of levies that inflate costs and deter consumer uptake. Telecom firms are pushing for exemptions on 5G equipment, mobile handsets, and ancillary infrastructure—measures aimed at dismantling barriers to rapid network expansion. More pointedly, they’ve targeted the 15% withholding tax as a punitive drag, advocating a slash to 8%, alongside a unified 16% General Sales Tax (GST) to foster broader usage. “These inconsistencies aren’t mere oversights; they’re active sabotage of digital inclusion,” the demands suggest, as operators also seek industrial electricity tariffs to rein in soaring operational expenses.
Infrastructure bottlenecks reveal yet more layers of administrative paralysis. The operators’ call to suspend Universal Service Fund (USF) and Research & Development (R&D) contributions for two years—followed by a halving to 1%—exposes how these funds, meant to bridge rural divides, have instead become fiscal black holes with minimal impact. Equally damning is their plea for a revamped Right of Way (RoW) policy: one that standardizes procedures nationwide to cut through the red tape of provincial fiefdoms and local extortion rackets that routinely delay tower deployments.
In a broader indictment of policy inertia, the telecom lobby has demanded the swift finalization of long-overdue frameworks for spectrum sharing, handset financing, and Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs). These tools, they argue, are non-negotiable for an “inclusive” 5G ecosystem, yet their protracted limbo reflects a governance vacuum where inter-ministerial silos and electoral cycles eclipse national priorities.
Industry analysts echo the operators’ concerns, noting that Pakistan lags behind regional peers like India and Bangladesh, where proactive reforms have accelerated 5G adoption. “The government’s hesitation signals a profound disconnect between policymaking and the realities of a digital economy,” said one expert, speaking anonymously. With the spectrum auction looming, the proposals serve as both a roadmap and a reckoning: will Islamabad seize this moment to plug its governance leaks, or risk condemning millions to the slow lane of connectivity?
As negotiations intensify, telecom leaders warn that without these fixes, 5G’s promise—of smarter cities, remote healthcare, and economic multipliers—will remain a mirage, trapped in the crosshairs of its own regulatory failures. The ball is now firmly in the government’s court.
